Villa Clara, also known as Cobble Villa, stood as a rare architectural time capsule in Long Beach, New York, representing the vision of the city's founder, State Senator William H. Reynolds. Built around 1912 at 657 Laurelton Blvd, this distinctive property was believed to be the sole surviving example of Reynolds' initial "English country villa" design concept for the barrier island. Constructed from hollow tile, cement, and cobble stone, the home was originally intended to set the standard for the new beach resort, boasting early 20th-century luxury features like a sun parlor, wine cellar, and steam heat. Its unique structure and early political significance having been owned by Reynolds and later by city attorney David Tolins make it an essential physical link to Long Beach's formative years and development.
The home gained its unique artistic identity and current name from the Steele family, who purchased it in 1976. The late owner, Clara Steele, an accomplished Italian artist, adorned the interior with extensive and celebrated trompe l'oeil paintings, transforming the villa into a documented artistic treasure that has been featured in local media. Beyond its architectural and political past, this artistic legacy establishes Villa Clara as a unique cultural asset. The property, cited as being on the National Register of Historic Places, has always been recognized as a significant piece of local heritage, preserving both the functional design of the era and the personalized artistry of a notable resident.
Despite its profound historical and artistic value, Villa Clara has been facing the end of its existence for years. In September 2022, a variance was sought to demolish the house to make way for two new residences, sparking a dedicated preservation effort. This action has led to ongoing legal challenges and strong public outcry from residents urging the City Council to intervene and protect the structure. The situation highlights a common conflict between private property rights and the desire for local historic preservation, underscoring the want for a resolution that safeguards this irreplaceable piece of Long Beach, NY history and culture. Ultimately privately owned property can be demolished or modified by the owner. Although this once loved landmark will always be remembered, the burden in repairs and the state of decay has led to the owners decision to finally take it down.
By Dylan Jensen
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Educators Realty
(516) 512-1872